Getty Images (2)

Have you ever crushed on two friends at the same time? How’d that work out for you?

It’s tearin’ up Gabby Sidibe‘s heart that she has to choose which former ‘N Sync hottie she’d rather date. Ah, such a dilemma! Even though the Best Actress nominee wants Justin Timberlake to be her Oscar night escort, she thinks JC Chasez is pretty damn ‘Precious’ too!

“My ideal dream date?” the 26-year-old actress pondered when HollywoodLife.com chatted with her Feb. 14 at the ACE Eddies Awards in Los Angeles. “While I do talk a lot about Justin, I love JC Chasez. He was the one who I planned to marry at the age of 16, and while I’m a little older now, I’m basically over it…but the 16 year old in me wants to say JC Chasez.”

Talk about a raging inner conflict! Luckily for Gabby, her decision has been made for her, given that Justin, 29, is taken by Jessica Biel. If she does end up going with JT, there will be no strings attached and she can still get it together with the single JC, 33, afterwards.

Who knows, Gabby — maybe you’ll be as lucky as Katie Holmes. She used to talk about her celeb crush being Tom Cruise and now look at her…she’s married to him!

Get More on Gabby:

1. Who Do You Think Deserves An Oscar For Their Role? Mariah Carey Or Gabourey Sidibe?