Who do YOU think Damon got wet & wild with: Elena, Katherine or Rose? Vote!

Ian Somerhalder dressed appropriately for his 32nd birthday — he wore his birthday suit! And he wasn’t alone: “I was naked with a beautiful girl all day,” Ian told People. “I had a shower scene that led into another scene where I was kind of half-naked and wet.” I’ll give you a minute to finish panting before we try to figure out who the lucky lady was.

One thing’s for sure: “It wasn’t [Paul Wesley as] Stefan,” Ian said. (I’m glad he cleared that up. I think we can all agree that Damon/Stefan is the one couple that would be too bizarre, even for The Vampire Diaries.)

So who do YOU think Ian spent his big day with? My money’s on Lauren Cohan, since Damon and Rose have spent the past few episodes getting down to business. And if it is her, it definitely gives us all hope that she’ll find a way to cure the werewolf bite she suffered from Jules (Michaela McManus) on the Dec. 7 episode.

Of course, knowing this show… it could always have been Nina Dobrev (as Elena, Katherine, or some sort of third option.)