Both of these successful stars opted for the same Zac Posen pre-fall frock — but who wore it better?

At the MTV Movie Awards on June 5 all eyes were on Reese Witherspoon when she was honored in this sexy Zac Posen number — but she wasn’t the last star to show off the dress!

Mary J. Blige sported the same get-up on July 1 at the 2011 McDonald’s 365Black Awards.

While both of these beauties looked fantastic in this exotic summer frock, I think Reese wore it way better! Mary J.’s blunt ‘do was a bit much with the get-up. Also, her sexy black pumps are just too plain for the event. On the other hand, I loved the soft wave in Reese’s hair. Her nude pumps made her legs look mile long and complete the look perfectly. Talk about looking like a lioness, Reese!

Alex Scerbak